• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Pegasus Pizza Oakway – Authentic Thin Crust Pizza & Hearty Gorgonzola Pear Salads in Eugene, OR

Pegasus Pizza Oakway in Eugene, OR, serves remarkable New Jersey–style pizza with a perfectly thin crust and generous toppings. The pizza boasts balanced flavors without overwhelming spices, appealing even to picky eaters. Beyond pizza, their Gorgonzola and pear salad with candied walnuts stands out—fresh, hearty, and bursting with harmony. Portions are generous, making each meal satisfying. Though the cozy interior offers limited seating, the friendly staff and charming outdoor space create a welcoming atmosphere. Pegasus Pizza Oakway excels at delivering authentic, flavorful dishes that leave a lasting impression, blending quality ingredients with genuine care. A must-visit for pizza and salad lovers alike.

Pegasus Pizza Oakway at a glance

  • Address 4 Oakway Center, Eugene, OR 97401, United States
  • Phone +1 541-344-0844
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Italian restaurant , Salad shop .

Photos & Gallery

Pegasus Pizza Oakway: Reviews & Ratings

Tonya Sprague
5

I had quite possibly the best salad I've ever had. It was the Gorgonzola and pear with candied walnuts. The flavor was perfection. I don't eat pizza. My boyfriend really enjoyed his. We will be back. He's happy that there's now a pizza place I'll go to.

Charlie Gipson
5

This is some of the best pizza I have had in years! Little Italy pizza. Staff was welcoming and friendly. Just an excellent experience!

Gary Schartz
4

A scrappy version of a pizzà jernt. Oakway be damned. This place is like a small local New Jersey place. A few tables. Supplies everywhere. Cheese, oregano, hot sauce, cups for water - anything you could need or desire to go with your pizza. I been eatin' at Sy's too.much lately. Gettin' spoiled over here. Nice people getting the job done.

Eileen F
5

Today, I had the $8.00 Lunch special. A huge slice of Cheese Pizza, a Gorgonzola Pear Salad & water with a splash of Lemonade in it. If you look at the little box my Salad came in, it seems quite small. Well, when I took it out & plated it, my dinner sized plate was HEAP full to the edges with crispy Greens, creamy Gorgonzola, a ton of fresh Pear slices & lots of Candied Walnuts. Then I poured the ample sized portion of house Vinaigrette on it & that Salad alone was a meal. Please take a look closely at the box of Salad vs the plate of Salad! How'd they fit all that into the tiny box? Must be magic! The flavor sure was magic! My Pizza slice was super yummy, cooked longer as I asked it to be. My slice was very generous in size. The sauce wasn't totally burdened with Italian seasoning either. If you have read my other reviews, you'll see that I am not a big fan of the heavy hand of spices, overtaking any dish. Also, I didn't sneeze, so no funny additive was in any of my food. That's pretty rare with Salad. I usually know that my Salad is totally filled with Sulfites, because it becomes a sneezefest, upon eating my Salad. The Pizza slice had just the right amount of Cheese & the Crust was super duper thin, with a nice chunky, doughy, fat, thick edge. Like fresh, baked bread, it tasted. She said my Lunch came with a fountain or a canned beverage, but I am not really a Pop drinker, so I opted for water with a Splash of the fountain Lemonade. The Chairs are all put up, so if you dine on premise, you'll need to eat outside, which is a cute little covered area. I know there are 2 other Pegasus locations as well, but I don't know if they allow dining in yet either. This location is very small. They do ask for Masking & Social Distancing still, at this Oakway location. My hats off to Pegasus Pizza, because my Palate & Tummy are both quite happy. The person who waited on me, was also super sweet & helpful. I shall be back. Thank you!

Dellisa Belveal
5

This spot has the MOST delicious pizza ever! My husband is a very picky pizza guy. And, in his words even the crust was worth eating!! We will definitely go back for take out. But, the interior was quite small and tight quarters for inside eating. The salads are LARGE for a house salad. You definitely won't go away hungry eating here.

Mari Kim
5

Pegasus last week on the recommendation of a girlfriend. Lunch special: Hawaiian and salad and soda for $10. Staff are friendly and pizza came out steaming hot. Loved it.

Location

  • Pegasus Pizza Oakway
    Pegasus Pizza Oakway
    4 Oakway Center, Eugene, OR 97401, United States Hotline: +1 541-344-0844

Nestled in the cozy confines of 4 Oakway Center, Pegasus Pizza Oakway offers an authentic taste that beckons pizza lovers and salad enthusiasts alike. This small, inviting spot captures the essence of a local New Jersey pizzeria with its no-frills ambiance and a warm, welcoming staff. From the moment you walk in—or more often, dine outside under the covered patio—you sense the dedication to genuine flavors and generous portions.

The true stars here are the pies and the salads. Customers rave about the thin-crust pizzas, baked to perfection with a delightfully doughy, thick edge reminiscent of fresh-baked bread. The sauce strikes a perfect balance, not overwhelming with Italian seasoning, allowing the cheese and crust to shine. Whether it's a classic Cheese slice or the celebrated Little Italy pizza, the taste experience is a nod to time-honored traditions made fresh daily.

Yet, the Gorgonzola and pear salad steals the show. What appears as a modestly packed box transforms into a plate heaped with crispy greens, creamy Gorgonzola, vibrant pear slices, and crunchy candied walnuts. This salad is not just an accompaniment but a fulfilling meal on its own. The house vinaigrette ties the elements together with a subtle magic that pleases the palate without artificial additives, making it a rare find for sensitive eaters.

Though the interior space is limited, and social distancing is observed, the hospitality remains generous. The thoughtful service adds to the overall experience, making every visit feel personal and satisfying. Pegasus Pizza Oakway proves that you don’t need a sprawling dining area or over-the-top decor to craft memorable, crave-worthy food. Here, simplicity meets quality, and every bite tells a story of passion, care, and culinary skill.